Skip to main content

Table 1 Descriptive statistics via ANCOVA analysis of implementation levels, English fluency and instructional method related to total change scores for life science knowledge gained

From: Integrating arts with STEM and leading with STEAM to increase science learning with equity for emerging bilingual learners in the United States

Implementation fidelity

Language fluency

Instructional method

Mean

Std. deviation

N

High implementation fidelity

English fluent

STEAM/STEM

7.29

4.49

24

STEM/STEAM

4.64

4.07

22

Total

6.02

4.45

46

Emergent bilingual

STEAM/STEM

6.11

4.97

18

STEM/STEAM

2.50

3.84

44

Total

3.55

4.47

62

Total

STEAM/STEM

6.79

4.68

42

STEM/STEAM

3.21

4.018

66

Total

4.60

4.61

108

Low to moderate implementation fidelity

English fluent

STEAM/STEM

4.00

3.44

14

STEM/STEAM

3.50

2.07

6

Total

3.85

3.05

20

Emergent bilingual

STEAM/STEM

5.00

3.465

5

STEM/STEAM

1.56

3.815

16

Total

2.38

3.945

21

Total

STEAM/STEM

4.26

3.385

19

STEM/STEAM

2.09

3.495

22

Total

3.10

3.57

41