Skip to main content

Table 2 Feedback levels

From: Development of Two-Dimensional Classroom Discourse Analysis Tool (CDAT): scientific reasoning and dialog patterns in the secondary science classes

Level

Main aspects

Focus

Feedback content type

Delivery method

Effects on learning

1

Evaluative, normative

Student

Grade, praise, evaluation, comparison with others

General comments, no reason, attention to “self”, too long, vague, difficult, or interruptive students’ prompts

Negative or no effects

2

Corrective, verification

Task

Correction, right answer, direct hint, try again,

Short, clear, fast in written and spoken

Sometimes effective

3

Elaborative, facilitative

Task

Location of mistakes, addressing information, hint/cue for the direction, specific error (what and why)

No correct answers, manageable units for students, considering students’ level, specific and clear, goal orientation

Effective almost always

  1. Synthesized from the studies of Hattie and Timperley 2007; Kluger and DeNisi 1998; Shute 2008